Janey Burton

PUBLISHING CONSULTANT

Editor & Contracts Negotiator

What is a manuscript assessment?

Who is the manuscript assessment service for?

Which book categories do you work with?

What information will you need from me?

What will I receive in my manuscript assessment report?

Can I see an example of your feedback before booking?

Can we have a follow-up session afterwards?

How much does a manuscript assessment cost?

How long will the manuscript assessment take?

Do you offer a partial manuscript assessment?

How do I book a manuscript assessment?

Any other questions?

 

‘Turning a manuscript into a book is easy; getting the manuscript ready to become a book is hard.’
— A. P. Fuchs

What is a manuscript assessment?

A manuscript assessment (also known as a manuscript appraisal, evaluation or critique) is a professional evaluation of a manuscript’s strengths and weaknesses, considering both its effectiveness as a piece of writing and its suitability for its intended readership and market.

An assessment identifies what’s working, what isn’t, and what the author can do to improve the manuscript. It considers elements such as structure, narrative arc, pacing, voice, characterisation, plot and dialogue, as appropriate to the work.

My assessments draw on over 20 years of experience in book publishing. As well as evaluating the manuscript on its own terms, I consider how it fits into its category, what readers of that category will expect, and how it might be positioned in the publishing market.

My aim is to provide clear, constructive and practical feedback that will help you make informed decisions about your manuscript and its next draft.

Who is the manuscript assessment service for?

A manuscript assessment can be particularly useful for:

  • Writers preparing for publication, who want to establish whether their manuscript is ready, or nearly ready, for submission to agents and publishers, or for self-publication.
  • Writers receiving vague or conflicting feedback from readers, who would benefit from a clear, objective assessment from an experienced publishing professional.
  • Writers who are stuck, who know that further work is needed but aren’t sure what to change or how to approach the next draft.
  • Writers who want to evaluate their manuscript against its objectives, including its suitability for the intended readership, its category or genre, and its potential within the market.

Which book categories do you work with?

I work with general and popular non-fiction and commercial fiction in all categories for adults.

In non-fiction, I particularly enjoy memoir, biography, careers and self-help books. In fiction, I’m most comfortable with mysteries, thrillers, comic fantasy and women’s fiction, including romance and cosy mysteries.

I don’t work with poetry or children’s books.

What information will you need from me?

When you first contact me, please attach a sample of the manuscript: the first three chapters or at least the first ten pages. I’ll also want to know the manuscript’s word count, category or genre, and intended readership. It’s also useful to know your publishing objectives: for example, whether you’re hoping to secure a traditional publishing deal or intend to self-publish, and a bit about you, your writing background, and your work on the book so far.

Please tell me about any particular concerns you have or questions you’d like the assessment to address. You can also send relevant additional documents, such as a synopsis and/or pitch letter.

What will I receive in my manuscript assessment report?

You’ll receive a detailed written report, tailored to your manuscript. I don’t follow a fixed template, as different manuscripts have different strengths, weaknesses and requirements.

Broadly, the report will discuss:

  • What is working well in the manuscript, and why.
  • What isn’t working, or could be developed further.
  • What you can do to address the problems and improve the work.

Depending on the manuscript, I’ll examine elements such as structure, narrative arc, pacing, characterisation, plot, dialogue, voice and style. I’ll also consider the work’s intended readership, its position within its category or genre, and its market potential.

Where useful, I’ll refer to specific chapters, scenes or passages, sometimes quoting directly from the manuscript to illustrate a point. I may also recommend further reading to help you develop particular aspects of the work.

The length of the report depends on the individual manuscript and what needs to be said about it. Previous reports have ranged from approximately 2,000 to 6,000 words.

A manuscript assessment is a structural and editorial evaluation, rather than a line edit or proofread. It concentrates on the manuscript as a whole and the substantive improvements that may be needed, rather than correcting individual sentences or typographical errors.

Can I see an example of your feedback before booking?

Yes. I can provide an anonymised extract from a romance, thriller or memoir manuscript assessment, so you can see the level of detail and the approach I take.

These examples are necessarily partial to protect the authors’ confidentiality. Just let me know which you’d prefer when you contact me.

Can we have a follow-up session afterwards?

Absolutely! We can arrange a complimentary follow-up call to discuss any points in the report that you’d like clarified: just get in touch.

If you’d like further advice or encouragement while rewriting and editing your manuscript, my mini consultation service is also available.

How much does a manuscript assessment cost?

The fee for a full manuscript assessment is £400 for manuscripts up to 50,000 words.

For manuscripts between 50,000 and 100,000 words, the fee is £400 for the first 50,000 words, plus £6 per additional 1,000 words.

For example:

Manuscript length Assessment fee
Up to 50,000 words £400
60,000 words £460
80,000 words £580
100,000 words £700

For manuscripts longer than 100,000 words, please contact me for a quotation.

A 50% non-refundable deposit is required to secure your booking, with the balance payable on delivery of the report.

You can read my full terms and conditions here.

How long will the manuscript assessment take?

My usual turnaround time is 3–5 weeks.

I’ll confirm the date on which I aim to deliver your report once I’ve received your deposit, manuscript and any additional material.

This allows time to read the manuscript carefully, consider it as a whole, and reflect on its strengths and weaknesses before preparing the report. That mulling time is an important part of producing a thoughtful and useful assessment.

Do you offer a partial manuscript assessment?

Yes. If you’re working on a manuscript and want to establish whether it’s developing successfully before investing further time in it, a partial assessment may be a useful alternative.

You can submit up to 30,000 words, together with an outline of the remaining chapters, so that I can consider both the material you’ve written and the direction in which the book is heading.

A partial manuscript assessment costs £250, with a usual turnaround time of 2–3 weeks.

How do I book a manuscript assessment?

There are two ways to get in touch:

  • Complete my contact form and select Manuscript Assessment.
  • Email me with Manuscript assessment booking in the subject line.

Either way, please tell me a little about your book, including its category or genre, word count, and what has prompted you to seek an assessment.

I’ll then be able to discuss availability and the next steps with you.

Any other questions?

You’re very welcome to email me if there’s anything else you’d like to know.